Disputed wills and estates are far from rare and it is often the least valuable assets in an estate that give rise to the bitterest arguments. In particular, a deceased person’s personal effects, such as their jewellery, pictures or even clothing, often carry many emotional connotations and it is these articles which are frequently the catalyst for a family dispute.

This was illustrated recently by a case brought in the High Court by the sister of the late footballer, George Best. Barbara McNarry was appointed the sole executor of her brother’s will. Mr Best died in 2005, at the age of 59, after a long and well-publicised battle with alcoholism.

Mr Best’s former wife, Alex, had in her possession at the time of his death a number of personal effects, including awards and other memorabilia. She intended to sell these items at auction, apparently arguing that they belonged to her as a result of the couple’s divorce settlement. Mrs McNarry claims that the items belong to the footballer’s estate and has obtained a High Court injunction preventing their sale pending a full hearing as to ownership of the disputed items.

In this case, the personal effects are potentially of significant monetary value. The newspaper reports of the case do, however, make reference to the emotional attachment felt to photographs of deceased family members and it is these sorts of items that often cause the most vehement disputes.

So, what arrangements can you make so as to ensure that your personal effects go to those you wish to have them after your death? The most important thing is to make a will so that your precise wishes with regard to these items are as clear as possible. It is not necessary to refer to all personal effects individually in a will. A very common way of dealing with them is to leave all personal effects to your executors to distribute in accordance with a separate list. This list can then be updated as circumstances change and, as it is not admitted to probate, it remains a private document.


    Get in touch

    Discuss your situation with an experienced Solicitor by filling out the form below or by ringing us on 0208 735 9770.

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.